Going fee-for-service sounds like freedom. For a lot of practices, it’s a slow leak in the new patient pipeline.
Why So Many Owners Want Out
The frustration is real. On average, dentists write off nearly 40% of their fees on PPO patients. That’s close to $4,000 of every $10,000 you produce on insured patients. Add claim delays, downgrades, and rental networks, and walking away from insurance starts to look like the only way to win.
But dropping a PPO is a one-way door. Getting back in can mean reapplying, re-credentialing, and accepting whatever fee schedule the carrier offers at that point.
The Risks No One Puts in the Brochure
- Patient attrition. Some patients will follow their benefits, not their dentist.
- Fewer new patients. Many patients search their carrier’s directory first. If you’re not listed, you’re not considered.
- Hygiene gaps. Lost recall patients leave open chairs that are hard to refill quickly.
- Front office strain. Your team takes on more out-of-network billing questions and patient pushback.
The Option Most Practices Never Consider
Dropping a PPO and accepting its current fees aren’t the only choices. A carrier’s fee schedule is negotiable, and so is how you participate.
Even practices that are totally out of network can often negotiate fees higher than their standard fees. That puts them in network on their own terms, back in the directories, and in front of far more new patients.
Before You Drop Anyone, Answer These Questions
- What percentage of your active patients carry this plan?
- What does this carrier pay compared with your other networks on your top 20 procedures?
- Has anyone actually asked this carrier for a fee increase in the last two years?
- Are your claims being routed through a lower-paying rental network?
- If you drop it, how will you replace those patients and that hygiene time?
If you can’t answer all five with real numbers, you’re not ready to drop the plan. You’re ready to analyze it.
Operate From a Position of Power
Sometimes leaving a network is the right move. When it is, it should be a planned, phased decision built on your data, not a reaction to a bad month. Our process audits your payor mix and fee schedules, models every option, and shows you the gain and the risk of each before you commit.
Know what you’d lose before you walk away. Request your complimentary PPO Revenue Assessment.
๐ https://pponegotiationsolutions.com/insurance-survey/

